| Player | Item | Description | Team | Rating | Acquired |
| Kevin HALLER | Card | 91-92 O-Pee-Chee | Buffalo | 10 | In Person |
| Kevin HALLER | Card | 94-95 Parkhurst | Montreal | 10 | In Person |
| Kevin HALLER | Card | 95-96 Stadium Club | Philadelphia | 9 | In Person |
| Roman HAMRLIK | Card | 98-99 Upper Deck | Edmonton | 9 | In Person |
| Jochen HECHT | Card | 99-00 Stadium Club | St. Louis | 10 | In Person |
| Jochen HECHT | Card | 94 S.Rookies Auto Phonex | Adler Mannheim (Germany) | 10 | In Person |
| Darby HENDRICKSON | Card | 97-98 Upper Deck | Toronto | 9 | In Person |
| Darby HENDRICKSON | Card | 95-96 SP | Toronto | 10 | In Person |
| Sean HILL | Card | 95-96 Upper Deck | Ottawa | 10 | In Person |
| Sean HILL | Card | 92-93 Fleer Ultra | Montreal | 10 | In Person |
| Corey HIRSCH | Card | 93-94 Score | NY Rangers | 8 | |
| Josh HOLDEN | Card | 97-98 Bowman CHL | Regina (WHL) | 10 | In Person |
| Bobby HOLIK | Card | 95-96 Upper Deck | New Jersey | 8 | |
| Brian HOLZINGER | Card | 97-98 Pacific Omega | Buffalo | 10 | |
| Brian HOLZINGER | Card | 96-97 UD CC | Buffalo | 10 | |
| Phil HOUSLEY | Card | 97-98 UD CC | Washington | 9 | In Person |
| Phil HOUSLEY | Card | 91-92 O-Pee-Chee | Winnipeg | 10 | In Person |
| Tony HRKAC | Card | 91-92 O-Pee-Chee | San Jose | 10 | |
| Tony HRKAC | Card | 91-92 Upper Deck | San Jose | 10 | |
| Tony HRKAC | Card | 89-90 Topps | St. Louis | 10 | In Person |
| Tony HRKAC | Card | 93-94 Leaf | St. Louis | 10 | In Person |
| Tony HRKAC | Card | 91-92 Score | San Jose | 10 | In Person |
| Mike HURLBUT | Card | 92-93 Classic PHP | Binghamton (AHL) | 10 | |
| Jarome IGINLA | Card | 98-99 Upper Deck | Calgary | 10 | In Person |
| Jarome IGINLA | Card | 99-00 UD Retro | Calgary | 10 | In Person |
| Jarome IGINLA | Card | 98-99 UD Choice | Calgary | 10 | In Person |
| Jarome IGINLA | Card | 99-00 Stadium Club | Calgary | 11 | In Person |
| Jarome IGINLA | Card | 97-98 UD CC | Calgary | 9 | In Person |
| Jarome IGINLA | Card | 99-00 Dynagon Ice | Calgary | 10 | Trade |
| Arturs IRBE | Card | 95-96 Topps | San Jose | 10 | |
| Brad ISBISTER | Card | 97-98 Donruss Elite | Phoenix | 6 | |
| Jaromir JAGR | Card | 98-99 Upper Deck | Pittsburgh | 8 | |
| Craig JANNEY | Card | 93-94 Premier | St. Louis | 10 | |
| Andreas JOHANSSON | Card | 99-00 Pacific | Ottawa | 10 | In Person |
| Andreas JOHANSSON | Card | 96-97 Be a Player | Pittsburgh | 9 | In Person |
| Craig JOHNSON | Card | 96-97 UD CC | Los Angeles | 10 | In Person |
| Olli JOKINEN | Card | 97-98 Donruss Elite | Los Angeles | 10 | |
| Olli JOKINEN | Postcard | Team Postcard | NY Islanders | 10 | |
| Kenny JONSSON | Card | 96-97 Score | Toronto | 10 | |
| Kenny JONSSON | Card | 95-96 Score | NY Islanders | 9 | |
| Sami KAPANEN | Card | 99-00 Stadium Club | Carolina | 10 | In Person |
| Sami KAPANEN | Card | 99-00 UD Retro | Carolina | 10 | In Person |
| Sami KAPANEN | Card | 99-00 Paramount | Carolina | 10 | In Person |
| Mike KEANE | Card | 98-99 Upper Deck | Dallas | 10 | In Person |
| Mike KEANE | Card | 91-92 Score | Montreal | 9 | In Person |
| Mike KEANE | Card | 95-96 Score | Montreal | 9 | In Person |
| Mike KEANE | Card | 93-94 Stadium Club | Montreal | 9 | In Person |
| Chad KILGER | Card | 96-97 UD CC | Phoenix | 9 | In Person |
| Chad KILGER | Card | 96-97 Score | Phoenix | 10 | In Person |
| Trent KLATT | Card | 97-98 UD CC | Philadelphia | 9 | In Person |
| Trent KLATT | Card | 97-98 Upper Deck | Philadelphia | 10 | In Person |
| Olaf KOLZIG | Card | 91-92 O-Pee-Chee | Washington | 9 | |
| Milan KRAFT | Card | 98-99 Team Set | Prince Albert (WHL) | 11 | |
| Igor KRAVCHUK | Card | 93-94 Fleer Ultra | Edmonton | 10 | In Person |
| Robert KRON | Card | 98-99 Pacific | Carolina | 8 | In Person |
| Robert KRON | Card | 96-97 Score | Hartford | 10 | In Person |
| Robert KRON | Card | 91-92 Upper Deck | Vancouver | 7 | In Person |
| Paul KRUSE | Card | 97-98 Be a Player | New York Islanders | 10 | Pack |
| Charline LABONTE | Card | 99-00 Prospects Sig. of Trad. | Acadie-Bathurst (QMJHL) | 11 | Pack! |
| Jamie LANGENBRUNNER | Card | 95-96 Upper Deck | Dallas | 8 | In Person |
| Ian LAPERRIERE | Card | 98-99 Pacific | Los Angeles | 10 | In Person |
| Ian LAPERRIERE | Card | 94-95 Leaf | St. Louis | 10 | In Person |
| Georges LARAQUE | 5x7 Printed Pic | I printed it myself (99-00) | Edmonton | 10 | In Person |
| Igor LARIONOV | Card | 91-92 O-Pee-Chee | Vancouver | 10 | |
| Sylvain LEFEBVRE | Card | 95-96 Score | Quebec | 10 | In Person |
| Manny LEGACE | Card | 93-94 Classic | Niagara Falls (OHL) | 10 | |
| Manny LEGACE | Card | 93-94 Classic 4-Sport | Niagara Falls (OHL) | 10 | |
| David LEGWAND | Card | 99-00 MVP 21st Century | Nashville | 10 | |
| Curtis LESCHYSHYN | Card | 91-92 O-Pee-Chee | Quebec | 10 | In Person |
| Trevor LETOWSKI | Card | 97-98 Bowman CHL | Sarnia (OHL) | 10 | In Person |
| Bill LINDSAY | Card | 96-97 Score | Florida | 9 | In Person |
| Bill LINDSAY | Card | 97-98 Upper Deck | Florida | 8 | In Person |
| Bill LINDSAY | Card | 92-93 Pro Set | Quebec | 9 | In Person |
| Dave LOWRY | Card | 95-96 Pinnacle | Florida | 10 | In Person |
| Dave LOWRY | Card | 96-97 Donruss | Florida | 10 | In Person |
| Dave LOWRY | Card | 96-97 Score | Florida | 9 | In Person |
| Dave LOWRY | Card | 95-96 UD CC | Florida | 7 | In Person |
| Dave LOWRY | Card | 94-95 Pinnacle | Florida | 10 | In Person |
| Dave LOWRY | Card | 99-00 Topps | San Jose | 10 | In Person |
| Dave LOWRY | Card | 91-92 Score US | St. Louis | 10 | In Person |
| Dave LOWRY | Card | 91-92 Score Canadian | St. Louis | 10 | In Person |
| Dave LOWRY | Card | 91-92 O-Pee-Chee | St. Louis | 10 | In Person |
| Dave LOWRY | Card | 90-91 O-Pee-Chee | St. Louis | 10 | In Person |
| Dave LOWRY | Card | 90-91 Upper Deck | St. Louis | 10 | In Person |
| Warren LUHNING | Card | 98-99 Upper Deck | NY Islanders | 10 | |
| Brad LUKOWICH | 5x7 Printed Pic | I printed it myself (99-00) | Dallas | 11 | In Person |
| Roman LYASHENKO | 5x7 Printed Pic | I printed it myself (99-00) | Dallas | 10 | In Person |
